Wednesday, October 20, 2010

Unit 3: Journal #3 (Quindlen) Stuff Is Not Salvation response

Marquise Nurse-Williams
Stuff Is Not Salvation Response
10-20-10
                                                                    Get Money!
        
                        In Anna Quindlen’s article, Stuff Is Not Salvation, she touches on the subject of American materialism and our desire for wants over needs. She starts off showing how crowds of people stampeded over a man who fell to the floor of a Wal-Mart store during a Black Friday sale, because they just needed get their grubby hands on that new microwave or television set for half the price. She goes on to speak of the national debt, as America falls into a trillion dollar credit card debt. Then she refers to how the average person’s cell phone only lasts about 16 months at the most, only because it has gone out of style. She then moves on to talk about the children and their want for the newest items in the toy commercials during Christmas and how they are unappreciated by Easter, collecting dust in the garage. As a solution, she finds the happiest people don’t rely on “stuff” or appliances to bring them happiness, but in fact she found a family in Pennsylvania that has learned to appreciate the small things. They kept their lives simple so that even the smallest gift would have meaning to it and wouldn’t be just another toy in the car hold. As an American citizen I find that Americans do put too much money into things they don’t need as people from other countries spend on necessity and rarely on what they want.
                    An example of American spending over necessity would involve my amazing cousin Ivor. He bought a $300,000 Rolls Royce with a house on the side on credit and while doing the payment he lost his job working in real estate. If he had any since, he would have bought a more practical car rather than something that he really didn’t need.
                   One example of how people are different in spending overseas, from my experience, was my time I got to spend with the foreign nationals Balad ,Iraq. They were people from all over the world. China, India, Russia, Yugoslavia and even Pakistan and they worked along side my coworkers and I. These people worked everyday with no days off for months to years at a time, for very low wages in a contracting gig called KBR. My buddy Kumar from India, told me the money he earns goes to his large family back home. It’s for food, water, shelter and nothing else. It was nearly the same situation for the rest of these people. When me and my American coworkers would give them birthday parties on the job and gifts, the smallest recognition for their time and effort meant the world to them. The job and the money it brought in meant everything to their families and their well being as well.
                    I find the American mentality to “keep up with the Kardashion’s” is a false salvation, as Quindlen proposes. Everyone wants to be on the top and in control, instead of feeling like they’re being lorded over I suppose. People believe money is what makes a person happy when in fact it’s the small things that people eventually learn makes a person happiest. Things like real family who would be there to help you when times get bad, or one real true friend over the hundreds pretending to be just that. Or even that special someone who would rather be with you than anyone else and those moments you get to spend with them. The all mighty dollar won’t buy these things, and many people in this blessed country forgot that. As Brian would say “We lost the values, but kept the weed…”

11 comments:

  1. Way to go on this one. You touched on some really tough stuff. Just like E-40 said; "Don't buy a $50,000 car before you buy a house." People need to realize that when they spend beyond their means, it only gets them into trouble in the end, and money is the root of all evil. Life is short and it should be spent with family and friends because no one is guaranteed tomorrow.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Great response! It is true that people in poorer countries are much more mature when dealing with money cause they usually will give it to family or for food. Sadly most Americans won't know what really matters unless they've experienced a lost.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I thought you had a great essay. You did a great job at responding to the prompt and you answered the prompt questions well. The thing I like the most from reading your essay was all the information you had and also the stories you told to back the information. I think that was the greatest strength. I thought you had a very well written essay.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This was so great you really understood the prompt very well.Glad you got straight to the point. Great examples how Americans like to keep up with certain celebrites.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hey great job your post was nicely done. Your story flowed very well, and you touched on all the points of this topic. Great job

    ReplyDelete
  6. This is a great response to the prompt. There was a clear image that a reader could picture through the examples you used. Be sure to put quotation marks around the article title. I enjoyed reading your response because you brought in factors of other people around the world and what they work for, being family, instead of spending on themselves. The discipline and effort other people put into their work was a good point. I also liked the reference to “Keeping up with the Kardashions” seeing as it’s just liked “Keeping up with the Jones’.” I’m not sure if you’ve seen the movie remake of it, but it shows a lot of good points about what Quindlen wrote about.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hey you did a really good job at grabbing the main idea of what the prompt was trying to say. It is true that most Americans are greedy but not all are, and most wont ever know that unless something like living on the streets changes that. But over all you were able to find key points and make them really stand out.

    ReplyDelete
  8. good punctuations and grammar nice job.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I loved your story it really related to the article. I know firsthand how poorly KBR workers are paid for the work they do especially in Iraq. They don’t focus on material possessions. If only others could take that in as an insight to stop spending so much.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I really like your composition of your prompt. Comparing the situation with great detail and examples. That really grabs my attention because I can imagine it in my head. Great response to the Prompt.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Excellent grammar and a very descriptive story to go along with it, great job. Now about your story, it tells me that you do understand the main point in the article, more than I do anyway, with your own experience. I couldn't agree with you more on how people in less fortunate countries tend to be a whole lot wiser in their spending and in what they spend it on.

    ReplyDelete